September 22, 2025

Cedar Shake vs. Asphalt Shingles: Aesthetic and Performance Trade-offs

What “cedar shake roofing” and “asphalt shingles” really mean, and why the choice matters

Homeowners weigh cedar shake roofing against asphalt shingles for different reasons. Cedar appeals to the senses first, with warm textures, depth, and color variation that make a roof feel like part of the landscape. Asphalt shingles win on predictability, cost, and ease of roof repair and roof maintenance. The right pick depends on climate, budget, and how you use your home. If you live under tree cover with frequent storm debris, your roof repair cost and cadence of roof inspection services will look different than a sun-baked, open-lot house. If you plan to sell in five years, average roof cost per square foot may matter more than a 40-year patina.

Both systems can deliver a reliable residential roofing solution when installed correctly. Each has its own failure modes, from granule loss and curling or buckling shingles on asphalt to split shakes and UV degradation of roofing materials on cedar. And while new roof installation pricing often drives the conversation, the lifetime mix of roof replacement cost, small emergency roof repair events after hail damage or wind damage to roof, and routine roof cleaning should shape your decision just as much.

How do they actually perform on real houses?

On steep-slope roofs, asphalt shingles dominate for a reason. They handle most North American climates, tolerate moderate installer variation, and play nicely with typical attic ventilation schemes. A decent laminated architectural shingle will often last 18 to 25 years in a mixed-climate region with regular preventive roof maintenance. In high UV zones or where ice dams are common, expect the shorter end of that range unless ventilation is dialed in. When problems appear, they tend to be visible and familiar: missing or damaged shingles after a storm, granule loss in gutters, or cracked shingles around penetrations. Roof repair is straightforward: replace the damaged course, reseal flashing, improve intake and exhaust to fight inadequate ventilation, and reset the ice and water barrier strategy at eaves to reduce freeze-thaw roof damage.

Cedar shake roofing can run longer, 25 to 40 years, provided you give it what it needs: air movement under the shakes, spacing for drainage, and fasteners that stand up to tannins and moisture. It sheds water beautifully because each shake is thicker and rougher, which breaks surface tension, and it can breathe even after a long rain. In wildfire-prone regions you must specify pressure-impregnated, fire-retardant shakes with proper underlayment, or consider wildfire-resistant roofing alternatives such as metal roofing or tile roofing. In wet, shaded zones, moss and algae growth on roofs and pest infestations on roofs can creep in faster on wood unless you maintain it. Repairs can be surgical, but access and matching weathered color take time, which affects roofing labor cost.

The real cost picture, not just the bid number

Price ranges vary by region, pitch, and complexity, but here is a practical frame. Asphalt shingles often land at a lower roof installation cost, with an average roof cost per square foot commonly in the neighborhood of 4 to 7 dollars for standard architectural shingles on simple roofs. Complex roofs with multiple valleys, skylights, and steep slopes push higher due to added flashing and safety setups. Cedar shake roofing can start around 8 to 14 dollars per square foot and go up for premium grades or labor-intensive patterns. Roofing labor cost is a big swing factor. Cedar crews need more time to stage, hand-sort shakes, and cut around dormers, which is why bids diverge.

Lifetime spend tells a clearer story. With asphalt, factor at least one midlife repair cycle for curling or buckling shingles, chimney leaks, or flashing damage, plus roof cleaning and occasional storm damage roof repair. Cedar demands periodic maintenance, such as gentle washing, checking for split shakes, and ensuring underlayment and battens ventilate properly. Budget for selective shake replacement every few years in harsh exposures. Roof financing options can level cash flow, but run an honest tally of interest costs versus the expected roof lifespan you will actually use during ownership. If you intend to move before year 12, asphalt’s lower entry cost often wins. If you plan to keep the property long term and will maintain it, cedar can justify itself with longevity and curb appeal.

How do weather and site conditions tilt the decision?

Climate plays referee. In heavy snow zones, both systems can work if the design handles snow load roof issues and prevents ice dams. A properly detailed cold roof with continuous ventilation, air sealing at the ceiling plane, and an ice and water shield at eaves is nonnegotiable. Asphalt is sensitive to sustained heat and UV in desert or high-altitude climates, where premium shingles and reflective granules help. Cedar fares well with thermal cycling but needs drying time after storms. In coastal wind zones, rated shingles with correct fastener schedules compete well, and cedar can perform if installed to wind specifications, but wind-driven rain can test any roof’s flashing around chimneys, skylights, and wall transitions.

Site exposure matters just as much as macro climate. A roof shaded by big oaks invites moss, algae, and slow drying, which increases maintenance for both materials, especially cedar. Open, sunny lots can bleach cedar faster but keep it dry. If you’re in hail alley, asphalt shingles with impact ratings can reduce claims frequency, though even impact-rated shingles are not hail-proof. Cedar can be dent resistant but still suffer split shakes under severe hail. Think about what typically hits your roof: tree damage to roof in storm corridors, UV intensity, and wind-driven debris.

Maintenance realities: what you will actually do

Maintenance makes or breaks the roof lifespan you achieve versus the brochure. roofing contractor Anoka, MN roofing contractor Albertville, MN roofing contractor Becker, MN roofing contractor Blaine, MN roofing contractor Brooklyn Park, MN roofing contractor Buffalo, MN roofing contractor Carver, MN roofing contractor Chanhassen, MN roofing contractor Chaska, MN roofing contractor Dayton, MN roofing contractor Eden Prairie, MN roofing contractor Edina, MN roofing contractor Jordan, MN roofing contractor Lakeville, MN roofing contractor Maple Grove, MN roofing contractor Minnetonka, MN roofing contractor Prior Lake, MN roofing contractor Ramsey, MN roofing contractor Wayzata, MN roofing contractor Otsego, MN roofing contractor Rogers, MN roofing contractor St Michael, MN roofing contractor Plymouth, MN roofing contractor Rockford, MN roofing contractor Big Lake, MN roofing contractor Champlin, MN roofing contractor Coon Rapids, MN roofing contractor Elk River, MN roofing contractor Monticello, MN roofing contractor Osseo, MN roofing contractor Savage, MN roofing contractor Shakopee, MN roofing contractor Burnsville, MN roofing contractor Golden Valley, MN roofing contractor Robbinsdale, MN roofing contractor Rosemount, MN roofing contractor St Louis Park, MN roofing contractor Roseville, MN roofing contractor Woodbury, MN roofing contractor Eagan, MN roofing contractor Richfield, MN For asphalt shingles, plan seasonal roof inspection services, clear clogged gutters to avoid poor drainage and water backing up under eaves, and keep an eye on vents, pipe boots, and step flashing. When you see curling or buckling shingles or granule drifts at downspouts, you are looking at age or heat stress, not just cosmetics. A small leak near a plumbing vent often costs little to fix if caught early, but it can turn into sheathing rot if ignored.

For cedar shake roofing, the checklist is more tactile. You want open keyways between shakes, intact butt thickness, and sound fasteners. Remove debris that holds moisture, keep nearby branches trimmed for sun and air, and schedule gentle cleaning if moss colonizes the surface. Avoid harsh pressure washing, which scars the wood. A preventive roof maintenance plan that budgets for selective shake swaps every few years, plus inspection after major storms, will extend service life. If you are not prepared for that hands-on approach, a high-end asphalt or metal roofing system may suit you better.

Installation quality: the quiet variable that changes everything

Roof installation quality swings performance more than material choice in many cases. I have seen a basic architectural shingle outlast a premium cedar roof because the shingle job used correct intake and exhaust ventilation, airtight ducts, and crisp flashing work, while the cedar was stapled too tight without under-course ventilation. New roof installation should always start with the attic and deck: air seal penetrations, verify insulation depth, and confirm vent balance to prevent moisture loads that drive roof aging from below. On the deck, replace spongy sheathing, and check nailing patterns, especially at hips and ridges, where wind loads spike.

Flashing details separate pros from the rest. Chimney leaks, skylight leaks, and sidewall transitions are where most roofs fail, not the field. On asphalt, layered step flashing with proper counterflashing and sealant choice matter. On cedar, each coursing change and penetration must still promote drainage. If a contractor shrugs off ventilation or suggests shortcuts around building code, expect a shorter lifespan and more emergency roof repair down the line. Comparing bids should include line items for underlayments, ice and water barriers, ridge vents, fasteners, and accessory metals, not just shingle or shake brand.

Appearance, resale, and neighborhood fit

Looks matter. Cedar delivers a richness that can elevate a craftsman, cottage, or lakeside home. It pairs well with stone, stucco, and natural siding, and it hides minor waviness in older decks because the thickness and texture distract the eye. Asphalt shingles have come a long way, with dimensional and designer profiles that mimic heavier materials. The upside is consistent color and a wide palette that fits most subdivisions and historic districts that don’t allow wood roofing. For multi-family roofing or commercial roofing projects where uniformity and low maintenance rule, asphalt or even metal roofing typically wins. For a one-off custom home, cedar can be the detail that sets the property apart.

Energy, sustainability, and eco-friendly roofing angles

The green roofs conversation is broader than plant-covered systems. Life-cycle footprint, recyclability, and operational energy all count. Asphalt shingles are petroleum based, but many manufacturers incorporate recycled content and offer tear-off recycling in select markets. Cool-color granules can reduce attic temperatures a few degrees, easing HVAC load. Cedar is a renewable resource, and sustainably harvested shakes store carbon, but transport, preservatives, and more frequent maintenance add nuance. If your goal is eco-friendly roofing with very low upkeep, standing seam metal in a cool color sometimes outperforms both. Solar shingles exist, yet their economics and serviceability differ from conventional panels and should be weighed against the roof’s geometry and shading.

When repair beats replacement, and when it doesn’t

Not every issue demands a roof replacement. A localized roof leak at a boot or a few cracked shingles after a mild wind event are classic roof repair jobs. On asphalt, repairing missing or damaged shingles and reseating flashing can buy many years. On cedar, replacing a cluster of split shakes and resettling ridge caps can stabilize a section. But if you see widespread granule loss, systemic blistering, or a sagging roof that hints at structural issues, it is time to scope replacement. The same goes for cedar with extensive cupping, punky butts, and pervasive fastener corrosion. If more than 20 to 25 percent of a slope needs intervention, replacement usually pencils out once you add roofing labor cost and the disruption of multiple service calls.

Insurance claims complicate the math. Hail damage or hurricane roof damage in coastal states can justify partial or full replacement if a qualified inspector documents impact across slopes. Keep a level head during storm-chaser season. Schedule a credible roof inspection and get a photo-rich report before signing anything. If you must stop a leak quickly, ask for a temporary emergency roof repair and a written scope for permanent work once adjusters weigh in.

Quick comparison: asphalt shingles versus cedar shakes

Factor Asphalt Shingles Cedar Shake Roofing Typical lifespan 18 - 25 years, climate dependent 25 - 40 years with maintenance Average cost per sq. ft. ~4 - 7 dollars ~8 - 14 dollars Maintenance level Low to moderate Moderate to high Fire and code considerations Broad Class A availability Requires rated, treated shakes for fire zones Repairs Fast, predictable parts and labor Skill intensive, color matching issues

Choosing a contractor without getting burned

I look for three things: proof of workmanship on similar roofs, ventilation and flashing fluency, and steady communication. Any roofer can quote a number. Fewer can show attic photos, detail the underlayment sequence, and specify fasteners by type. Ask them to walk you through their plan for your valleys, chimneys, and skylights. If they gloss over those areas, that is a red flag. Verify licensing, insurance, and references that include at least one roof older than five years. Compare roof warranty coverage terms, and read what voids them, like unbalanced ventilation or third-party penetrations. If you expect to finance, ask how roof financing options interact with manufacturer warranties.

If you need a starting point to vet local talent, you can check a roofer’s BBB profile to corroborate years in business and complaint resolution. After severe weather, use a structured approach to assess damage before inviting bids, such as this practical guide on ways to inspect your roof after bad weather. For homeowners still weighing the fork in the road, this perspective on whether to repair or replace a roof can help frame your decision. And if you are leaning toward metal for wildfire-resistant roofing or durability reasons, you can learn more about metal roofing contractors and compare options.

DIY touch-ups or a costly gamble?

Some tasks are homeowner friendly: clearing gutters to prevent poor drainage, replacing a cracked plastic pipe boot with an identical part, or reseating a loose shingle tab with roofing cement on a low-pitch, single-story roof. Anything that involves reworking flashing, stepping onto steep slopes, or cutting into multiple shingle courses is best left to pros. The risk is not only falling. A sloppy repair can drive water sideways into the deck, causing hidden rot that shows up a season later as a soft spot or a musty attic. DIY cedar work adds more risk, because pulling the wrong fastener or breaking neighboring shakes can escalate a simple fix. If you must tackle a small asphalt patch, document the area with photos, use matching materials, and schedule a professional roof inspection within a week to verify the repair.

Preventive steps that actually extend roof lifespan

Think upstream. Most roof problems start with heat and moisture in the attic or with water that cannot drain. Air seal the ceiling plane, especially around can lights, bath fans, and top plates. Vent bath and kitchen fans outdoors, not into the attic. Balance intake and exhaust ventilation to hit the manufacturer’s net free area targets. Keep trees trimmed to avoid constant shade and abrasive limb contact. Clean gutters and downspouts twice per year, more if you have heavy leaf fall, and consider quality guards that do not trap granules. After any severe storm, do a ground-level scan for wind damage to roof, displaced ridge caps, or flashing that has lifted at the chimney cricket. Small, timely interventions head off emergency roof repair calls later.

FAQs: straight answers to common roofing questions

Below are concise answers that reflect how a roof behaves over years, not just on install day.

How can I tell if a roofer is exaggerating the damage?

Ask for photos with context: wide shots of each slope and close-ups with a ruler in frame. Request a prioritized list separating safety issues and active leaks from cosmetic wear. If the report claims systemic failure but shows only a few cracked shingles or minor granule loss, get a second opinion. Independent roof inspection services that do not sell installs can provide neutral documentation.

Is patching a leak just a temporary fix that guarantees I will pay more later?

No, not if the repair targets root causes. Replacing a failed pipe boot, reworking step flashing, or adding an ice and water shield at an eave transition can restore full service life to that area. Temporary tar patches without addressing flashing or ventilation are what lead to repeat calls.

Why do roofing quotes vary so wildly for the same job?

Scope and assumptions. One contractor may include full tear-off, deck repairs, upgraded underlayments, and ridge ventilation, while another overlays existing shingles with minimal flashing work. Labor rates, insurance, and material grade choices also contribute. Ask for itemized scopes so you can compare apples to apples.

What are the most common upsells, and do I need them?

Ice and water shield beyond code, synthetic underlayment upgrades, and premium ridge vents are common. In snow and ice climates, extra membrane at valleys and eaves is smart. Synthetic underlayment is often worth it for durability and walkability. Premium ridge vents make sense if intake ventilation and baffle details are correct. Be wary of add-ons that do not address your climate or roof design.

How long should a solid repair last?

On asphalt, a proper flashing or shingle replacement typically lasts the remainder of the roof’s life on that slope, often 5 to 15 years. On cedar, a well-fitted shake replacement should blend in and perform for many seasons, though color uniformity changes with weathering.

Are free roof inspections just a sales pitch?

Sometimes. Many are legitimate, but they are often tied to replacement quotes. That is fine if you expect to compare bids. If you want a neutral condition report, pay a fee to an inspector who does not sell installation. The cost is small insurance against biased recommendations.

Why a Roof Repair Is Rarely Just a Roof Repair

Choosing between cedar shake roofing and asphalt shingles is not a beauty contest or a short-term budget decision. It is a judgment about how your home sheds water, breathes, and ages in your specific climate, under your trees, with your appetite for upkeep. Asphalt shingles keep costs predictable and roof replacement straightforward, which is why they dominate residential roofing. Cedar shakes reward care with longevity and character that is hard to fake, at the price of more frequent touch points. Either can fail early if installation cuts corners on ventilation and flashing, and either can exceed expectations when those details are respected.

If you remain undecided, gather two or three itemized bids, confirm attic ventilation and underlayment strategies in writing, and factor the real annualized cost rather than only the install price. Look at how you live, plan for routine maintenance, and set aside a modest reserve for storm damage roof repair. Thinking this way helps you avoid costly surprises, extend roof lifespan, and choose a system that fits your home as well as your calendar and wallet.

The Place for Roofers is your go-to hub for everything roofing. From installation tips and product insights to industry news and business know-how, we bring together the resources roofers need to stay sharp and ahead of the curve. Whether you’re on the jobsite, running a crew, or just looking to keep up with what’s new in the trade, this is the community built for you.